U.S. Supreme Court declines to review dispute over Roberto Clemente's image on Puerto Rico license plates
By Ferraiuoli LLC
The U.S. Supreme Court declined on November 9, 2026, to review an appeal filed by Roberto Clemente's sons concerning the use of the Puerto Rican baseball legend's image on vehicle registration plates and tags issued by the Government of Puerto Rico.
Roberto Clemente Jr., Luis Roberto Clemente and Roberto Enrique Clemente, together with two companies they own, had filed a lawsuit against the Puerto Rican government over its use of their father's image on commemorative plates distributed in 2022 without their authorization.
The plaintiffs argued that the use infringed rights associated with the trademark and constituted an appropriation of intangible private property in violation of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which provides protection against certain government takings.
According to the lawsuit, the program generated approximately US$15 million for Puerto Rico. The family sought to prevent further use of the image and claimed US$45 million in damages, as well as an additional US$3.15 million for alleged trademark infringement.
A federal district court in San Juan had dismissed the case. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit subsequently upheld that decision in part and rejected the argument that the trademark use constituted an unconstitutional taking.
Before the Supreme Court, the plaintiffs' lawyers challenged the lower courts' interpretation of constitutional protection for intangible assets, including trademarks. The Government of Puerto Rico argued that the family's position overstated the scope of the previous appellate ruling.
The Supreme Court's decision not to hear the appeal does not constitute a ruling on the merits of the underlying claims. According to information published by Reuters, the family indicated that it intends to continue litigating the claims that remain pending before the lower courts.
